A hospital trust in Bristol has been accused of risking lives after raising its nurse-to-patient ward ratio to dangerously high levels, having allegedly dismissed staff concerns and national guidance on safe staffing.
University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust (UHBW) has introduced a blanket policy across its hospitals that assigns one nurse to 10 patients (1:10) for all general adult wards. This ratio, which previously stood at 1:6 or 1:8 depending on the ward, rises to 1:12 for nights shifts.
The new policy, which is applicable to Bristol Royal Infirmary (BRI) and Weston General Hospital, also extends to all specialist high-care wards, which treat patients with life-threatening conditions such as epilepsy and anaphylaxis.
Nurses at the trust have expressed their anger over the decision, saying they were never fully consulted by senior officials. Many are fearful that patient safety will be compromised as the second coronavirus wave intensifies, culminating in the unnecessary loss of life.
Patients who would have extra nursing staff because they are very acutely unwell and need close observation I think are going to unnecessarily die, one nurse at BRI told The Independent.
Watch more
Or if they survive, theyll suffer long-term conditions because things were missed as they dont have the staff at their bed side to watch the deterioration.
Some nurses claims that they have been forced to look after up to 16 patients during their shifts due to severe staff shortages.
The trusts new ratio exceeds guidance set out by National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), which warns that people are at risk of harm in wards where there is one nurse for eight or more patients.
The link between patient safety and nurse staffing levels has been repeatedly evidenced in research and was made clear during the public inquiry into the Stafford Hospital care disaster, in which hundreds of patients suffered neglect and abuse after hospital managers slashed nurse staffing levels to save money and meet targets.
Multiple peer-reviewed studies have shown a ratio of nurses to patients that is 1:8 or higher can also result in patient deaths on medical wards.
Each area should be individually assessed, another nurse said. Theyve put in place a blanket policy which goes against NICE and doesnt give any consideration to the needs of the different wards and their patients.
Exemptions for the new nurse-patient ratio have been made for critical care and High Dependency Units (HDU), according to a leaked email circulated among managerial figures at Bristol Royal Infirmary.
In the email, sent out on 12 November, UHBW explained that the difficult decision had been made as a result of the unprecedented times, adding that the trust was in a designated critical incident.
The Trust demand for agency nurses is outstripping supply so we need to work on the basis that shifts will not all be covered, the email reads.
Nursing and midwifery leaders need to change their mind set and risk tolerance of what is safe under business as usual and what is safe in an exceptional critical incident.
Covering staffing gaps may need to include the use of non-nursing staff into support roles.
Nurses who have spoken with The Independent say they were informed about the new ratio via posters that were put up throughout Bristol Royal Infirmary. Others says they found out after a colleague obtained a copy of the email before circulating it among their peers.
1/51UK news in pictures
UK news in pictures
18 November 2020
UK PARLIAMENT/AFP via Getty Imag
UK news in pictures
17 November 2020
People gather on the the Comedy Carpet in front of the Blackpool Tower waiting for the funeral cortege of entertainer Bobby Ball to pass on its way to Carleton Crematorium in Blackpool
PA
UK news in pictures
16 November 2020
Shipping companies and retailers have complained of delays in unloading arriving freight, with one ship told it could wait up to 10 days for a berthing slot
Getty
UK news in pictures
15 November 2020
Rainbow over Gwrych Castle in Abergele, North Wales, where the new series of Im A Celebrity…Get Me Out Of Here! is taking place
PA
UK news in pictures
14 November 2020
Hindu monks set up Diya lamps at the BAPS Neasden Temple, London, on this morning of Diwali
BAPS Media
UK news in pictures
13 November 2020
Dominic Cummings, special advisor for Britain’s Prime Minister Boris Johnson leaves 10 Downing Street
Reuters
UK news in pictures
12 November 2020
A surfer silhouetted against the waves at Tynemouth, near North Shields
PA
UK news in pictures
11 November 2020
People walk past the Tommy statue, officially named 1101, on Terrace Green by the seafront in Seaham, County Durham, on the anniversary of Armistice Day. Across the UK people fell silent in remembrance of the nation’s war dead, as the coronavirus pandemic limits public commemorations
PA
UK news in pictures
10 November 2020
Number 10 special advisor Dominic Cummings waits to be admitted to 10 Downing Street in London
AFP via Getty
UK news in pictures
9 November 2020
A mural of the president of the United States, Donald Trump which has been painted on the side of Islington Mill arts hub in Salford, Manchester
PA
UK news in pictures
8 November 2020
Chelsea pensioners watch a Remembrance Sunday service from their windows at the Royal Hospital Chelsea
Reuters
UK news in pictures
7 November 2020
D-Day veteran Jim Healy, 95, from Manchester who is taking part in the Royal British Legion’s doorstep silence for Remembrance. Jim was a Corporal in the Royal Marines and was coxswain of a landing craft assault on June 6, 1944 and will observe the Two Minutes Silence on Sunday by standing on his doorstep
PA
UK news in pictures
6 November 2020
The sunrises over woodland in Ashford, Kent
PA
UK news in pictures
5 November 2020
Two men walk over a nearly deserted Westminster Bridge, in foggy conditions, at the start of a four week national lockdown for England
PA
UK news in pictures
4 November 2020
Laura Martindale, manager of The Rocket public house in Whiston, pours away spoilt beer that has gone off after the pub was placed into tier three and now faces a four week lockdown ahead of a national lockdown for England
PA
UK news in pictures
3 November 2020
An oast house surrounded by autumn colours in the morning sunshine near Hawkhurst in Kent
PA
UK news in pictures
2 November 2020
Large waves crash over the harbour wall in Newhaven, East Sussex, during strong winds
PA
UK news in pictures
1 November 2020
Shoppers queue outside Ikea in Batley, West Yorkshire, after Boris Johnson announced a new national lockdown will come into force in England next week
PA
UK news in pictures
31 October 2020
Boris Johnson announces new restrictions in No 10
Getty
UK news in pictures
30 October 2020
The hallway of the Halloween house of Conor Pilkington (centre), 23, from Gateshead, Tyne and Wear, who has gone all out this year with his Halloween display. Conor has spent an extra £5000 to make it extra special due to the covid pandemic
PA
UK news in pictures
29 October 2020
Chief of Defence Staff General Sir Nick Carter (centre) joining members of all three armed services, in Waterloo Station, London, to support the Royal British Legions Poppy Appeal by collecting donations and selling poppies on London Poppy Day
PA
UK news in pictures
28 October 2020
Surfers take to high waves caused by Atlantic swells in Mullaghmore in Co Sligo
PA
UK news in pictures
27 October 2020
A rare giant Japanese spider crab is moved into the sale room during a preview of the forthcoming Evolution Sale at Summers Place Auctions, Billinghurst, West Sussex
PA
UK news in pictures
Felixstowe Port Congested Amid Brexit Stockpiling And Pandemic Pressures
Getty
UK news in pictures
26 October 2020
A television crew prepare to do a live transmission opposite the Nave Andromeda, an oil tanker berthed at Southampton docks, southwest England. British soldiers yesterday boarded the tanker and detained seven suspects, the defence ministry said, after the crew were forced to take shelter from stowaways who threatened them
AFP via Getty
UK news in pictures
25 October 2020
Staff from British Divers Marine Life Rescue and Tynemouth Aquarium release three seal pups at St Marys Lighthouse in Whitley Bay. They were rescued after being found abandoned on the North East coast
PA
UK news in pictures
24 October 2020
Edinburgh University students protest against the false promise of ‘hybrid learning’ to new and returning students during the Covid-19 pandemic in Edinburgh, Scotland. The protest was organised to enable the students to show their anger and disappointment to the University of Edinburgh, after the students felt they were misled after they returned to find the vast majority of their lectures and contacts were all online
Getty Images
UK news in pictures
23 October 2020
The sun rises over the Severn crossing as traffic crosses from England into Wales, where a countrywide firebrake lockdown will begin from 6pm today until 12.01am on 9 November
PA
UK news in pictures
22 October 2020
EU chief Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier wearing an EU-flag themed face mask arriving at a conference centre in central London to attend a new round of trade talks with the UK
AFP via Getty
UK news in pictures
21 October 2020
The RRS Sir David Attenborough, the UK’s most advanced polar research ship, passes The Royal Liver Building after leaving Cammell Laird shipyard, Birkenhead, Merseyside. The crew are scheduled to conduct 14 days of technical trials off the coast of North Wales before the the shipyard formally hands it over to the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) and the British Antarctic Survey (BAS) crew for intensive training at Holyhead Port. The new polar ship will transform UK research in the polar regions and will be used on BAS missions which are critical for understanding and making sense of changing climate.
PA
UK news in pictures
20 October 2020
Prime Minister Boris Johnson outside Downing Street, ahead of a Cabinet meeting at the Foreign and Commonwealth Office
PA
UK news in pictures
19 October 2020
A man walks past a mosaic on a wall in Manchester
Reuters
UK news in pictures
18 October 2020
Cyclists cross a bridge over Flechs Water near to Brockenhurst in the New Forest
PA
UK news in pictures
17 Ocotber 2020
Pedestrians walk pas the Royal Seabank Hotel in Blackpool as Lancashire enters tier 3 of the governments coronavirus alert system
Getty
UK news in pictures
16 October 2020
A person wearing a face mask is reflected in an art work entitled “A=V” by Ben Cullen Williams in Covent Garden, London
REUTERS
UK news in pictures
15 October 2020
A gallery technician poses next to The Seagram Murals, by artist Mark Rothko during the New Collection Displays photocall at Tate Britain in London
Getty Images
UK news in pictures
14 October 2020
A red deer stag stands behind females, called hinds, during the rutting (breeding) season which takes place during autumn, in Bushy Park, south west London
AP
UK news in pictures
13 October 2020
RAF personnel speak to residents in Selly Oak, close to the University of Birmingham, assisting with Birmingham City Councils Drop and Collect coronavirus test distribution, as the local authority attempt to stem the rise of cases in the area
PA
UK news in pictures
12 October 2020
A member of staff pours a drink in the Richmond pub in Liverpool as Prime Minister Boris Johnson reads a statement on television, as parts of the North of England are bracing themselves for the most stringent Tier 3 control
PA
UK news in pictures
11 October 2020
Steampunks attend the ‘socially distanced’ Haworth Steampunk Weekend, in the quiet village in the Pennine hills of West Yorkshire
PA
UK news in pictures
10 October 2020
Members of the public watch the koi fish in the Kyoto Garden at Holland Park in London. Temperatures during the day on Saturday will be between 10C and 14C, but set to plunge as low as 1C overnight
Getty Images
UK news in pictures
9 October 2020
An employee pulls a pint in the Tib Street Tavern in Manchester, as Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak announces the government will pay two thirds of the wages of staff in pubs, restaurants and other businesses if they are forced to close under new coronavirus restrictions
PA
UK news in pictures
8 October 2020
A jogger runs over the Armstrong Bridge in Jesmond, Newcastle surrounded by Autumn colours
PA
UK news in pictures
7 October 2020
Artist Hannah Uzor with her painting of Sarah Forbes Bonetta, Queen Victorias African goddaughter, at Osborne, the Queens seaside home on the Isle of Wight. The organisation is displaying the portrait as part of a plan to feature works of overlooked black figures connected with its sites
English Heritage/PA
UK news in pictures
6 October 2020
Two swimmers run into the sea as the sun rises over Boscombe beach in Dorset
PA
UK news in pictures
5 October 2020
Veteran fundraiser Lloyd Scott, who is attempting to climb the Three Peaks whilst wearing a deep sea diving suit, is followed by members of his support team during his challenge on Ben Nevis in Scotland
PA
UK news in pictures
4 October 2020
Liverpool players look dejected after their Premier League match against Aston Villa ended 7-2 at Villa Park stadium in Birmingham
AP
UK news in pictures
3 October 2020
People on a Northern Line train in London, after the 10pm curfew pubs and restaurants are subject to in order to combat the rise in coronavirus cases in England
PA
UK news in pictures
2 October 2020
England’s Charlotte Banfield takes part in a practice session ahead of the 2020 Korev Lager English Adaptive Surfing Open at The Wave in Bristol which takes place tomorrow
PA
UK news in pictures
1 October 2020
A worker spray cleans the Beatles statue in Liverpool
PA
UK news in pictures
30 September 2020
An actor dressed as pantomime dame waves a flag at the entrance of a theatre before marching on Parliament to demand more support for the theatre sector amid the COVID-19 pandemic, in London
AP
In all but one case, where a ward manager communicated the changes to staff, no attempts were reportedly made to consult nurses about how their job responsibilities would be changing under the policy.
It hasn’t been spoken about with the people who are dealing with the conflicts that are going to arise from it, a third nurse at BRI told The Independent. At the end of the day it’s unsafe patient care. Its terrifying.
When it comes down to treatment being missed or a patient having a fall because they’re not being looked after properly, anything that’s gone wrong down to human error, its going to come straight back to me and I’ll risk losing my pin out of something which isn’t safe to begin with and I have no control over.
Nurses based in the hospitals general wards said that they have not been given any guidance over how to handle their increased workload, which patients to care for first, what health demands to focus on and whether they should dismiss the basic duties of their job.
Management arent even willing to have a discussion about what are the expectations of us. There have been no-follow up convos when staff asked about this, the first nurse said. In regard to nutrition are we expected to still help with that?
Are we still expected to turn vulnerable people over every two to four hours? If people are incontinent are we expected to help them as quickly as before? Or is it just the normal thing that people who cant go to the toilet themselves sit in dirty pants and their skin deteriorates further?
If someone is deteriorating, are we expected to be there and forget eight or nine other patients while we look after this one sick deteriorating person? We just dont know. Its really frightening for us.
Having already faced the brunt of the first wave, and suffered enormous mental strains as a result, nurses at BRI warned that their own wellbeing was on the line amid such conditions.
Myself and many other nurses are finding a career we were once so passionate about crumbling before our eyes, a member of staff told The Independent. We are tired, burnt out, stressed and anxious walking into the hospital, completely unaware of what to expect day to day.
Another said that there had been no additional mental health support rolled out for nurses at the hospital, despite the increased work demands.
Last month, The Independent reported that fears are mounting for the wellbeing of thousands of NHS doctors and nurses who are suffering from burnout during the coronavirus pandemic, with mental health conditions accounting for up to 20 per cent of absences at leading hospitals.
Nurses on the frontline of the pandemic are being pushed to the brink
The issue is expected to become more acute as hospitalisations from Covid-19 continue to rise during the second wave, experts warned, placing greater pressure on under-staffed wards while jeopardising patient safety.
One nurse associated with the campaign group Nurses Say No Bristol expressed concern that the new ratio would become the norm for the Trust throughout the rest of the pandemic and beyond.
If this does work and there are no adverse reactions to it, is this going to become the new norm? he told The Independent. Management might say You managed during the cover crisis, youll just have to stick to this.
He insisted that if nurses were going to be burdened with more work, it was only fair to increase wages and ensure the appropriate safety and support protocols are put in place. He added that management at UHBW needed to introduce a rolling review of all near-misses and accidents for wards were the nurse-patient ratio exceeds 1:8.
In response to the claims, Carolyn Mills, chief nurse at University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation Trust, said: This is not a blanket change to nurse to patient ratios in our hospital but a clinically-led decision we have taken in some areas where it is safe and appropriate to do so and to help us manage the increasing demand for our services during this global pandemic.
These decisions are under constant review based on clinical and staffing needs on shift by shift basis while senior clinicians are also on hand to offer wellbeing support and care to colleagues if required.
Exclusive: Staff warn people ‘are going to unnecessarily die’ after major Bristol hospital trust introduces blanket policy that will see one nurse assigned to 10 patients for all general adult wards
